Showing posts with label movies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label movies. Show all posts

Sunday, June 19, 2011

Edinburgh Film Festival Round-Up

By Jordan

Earlier this week I attended the opening three days of the 65th Edinburgh International Film Festival. It was my first film festival, and I attended it while on vacation in the UK (a vacation I will return from later this week; devotees of Review to Be Named can expect the blog to be back on its regular schedule after Wednesday). I did not attend it as a member of the press (for anyone who is at all confused, I am not a member of the press, just your standard amateur mucking it up for the real critics), and therefore participated in fewer screenings than I might have otherwise. I saw seven films over my three days at the festival: three revivals (screenings of Jim Jarmusch's Stranger Than Paradise, Sara Driver's You Are Not I, and Alexander Mackendrick's 1949 classic Whisky Galore!) and four UK Premiere's. Instead of writing four full reviews of the movies I saw, I thought it best to include short capsule reviews of all four, including grades as my standard regular length reviews do. You'll see more inter-review references than usual in these capsules, and a few asides about the festival experience, so think of these less as considered reviews and more as reports from the field. Without further ado, here are my thoughts on the four films I had the chance to experience at the Edinburgh International Film Festival:

The Guard:

Directed by John Michael McDonagh (brother of In Bruges director Martin McDonagh), The Guard is in several respects very similar to his brother's film. Also a pitch-black comedy starring a caustic Brendan Gleeson, The Guard is a self assured debut that knows exactly how clever it is and doesn't pull any punches as a result. Gleeson is stellar and hysterical as Sergeant Gerry Boyle, a boozy, drug-friendly, hooker frequenting small town cop who reluctantly joins forces with a standard, strait-laced, "by the book" FBI Agent Wendell Everett (Don Cheadle, who very subtly portrays Everett's transformation from shock to annoyance to loyalty in regards to Boyle) to bring down a drug cartel who murderously await a shipment of $500 million worth of cocaine (though, as Boyle continuously insists, the feds tend to overestimate the "street value" of their busts). In many ways, The Guard is a fairly standard, if a few shades darker, buddy cop comedy, but it sets itself apart by being far more hysterical, and far more politically incorrect than its more generic counterparts. Hilarious, engrossing, and just a full out blast to watch, The Guard is the kind of film that will make fans of In Bruges wait excitedly for the next project from one of the brothers McDonagh.

Grade: A-

Oliver Sherman:

A compelling study of the effects of warfare and of mankind's dual capacity for compassion and violence, Oliver Sherman is a tense tour de force. Propelled by three stellar lead performances from Garret Dillahunt as Sherman Oliver, an ex-soldier who survived a shot to the head but never got over the psychological aftermath, Donal Logue as Franklin Page, the man who saved Sherman's life and has since settled into a quiet, peaceful existence and Molly Parker as Irene, page's serene but willful wife, the film follows Sherman's surprise arrival on the Page's doorstep and its effects on both him and on the patient and, initially at least, understanding Page's. Written and directed assuredly by first timer Ryan Redford, Oliver Sherman is a stellar look at three people pushed to their limits and beyond and the long term consequences of trauma for two very different men.

Grade: A

Our Day Will Come:

The feature-length debut of director Romain Gavras (most well known for his inflammatory video for MIA's "Born Free"), Our Day Will Come deals with many similar concerns in its examinations of two red-heads who feel ostracized by their society and set off on a nihilistic road trip towards Ireland, where they believe they may finally gain acceptance. Remy (a forceful Olivier Bartelemy) feels alienated, disaffected, isolated and bullied by everyone around him until he assaults his mother and sister and escapes their control. He quickly falls under the thrall of Patrick (Vincent Cassel, stellar as always) a charismatic, racist, violent psychoanalyst who tells Remy he can be his own Messiah and lead redheads into a day of prominence. A pitch black comedy that at times becomes a disturbingly violent examination of alienation and racism in French society, Our Day Will Come is a road comedy for the deeply troubled. While the film at times loses itself in surrealistic tangents (one of which features Cassel in a threesome while a stone faced red headed girl watches from a couch) and is often too on the nose in its "red heads as minorities discriminated against in French society" metaphors, Our Day Will Come is consistently interesting and occasionally moving, with two great performances and a propulsive pace that moves on from any useless or uninteresting tangent quickly enough that none prove too distracting. For much of its runtime, I was reminded of a remark made by Don Cheadle in The Guard soon after he meets Brendan Gleeson: "I don't know whether you're really fucking smart or really fucking stupid." Gleeson just smiles in response, and Our Day Will Come seems to grimace at the same question. It doesn't know the answer, and neither does Gavras (who was often befuddled and unable to answer questions during the Q&A that followed the screening), but neither seems to care. Both the film and its director seem satisfied to just be along for the ride.

Grade: B (though I reserve the right to reevaluate in either direction if I get the chance to see the film again upon its wide release)

On the Shore:

Police Captain Michel Matarasso (played well by the expressive French character actor Daniel Duval) is plagued by nightmares and grows weary of his job, and his listless relationship with a stunt coordinator. All of this changes, though, when he discovers the body of a young woman who has committed suicide and begins to involve himself in the lives of her former friends, family and colleagues. Ostensibly, the film aims to examine the need for love and the pain of loneliness, but far too often it becomes a meandering mess, confusing silence for subtlety and muddled writing for evocative mystery. The film feels needlessly, endlessly drawn out at 90 minutes (a fact which was not helped by the stifling heat in the theater, which got so bad I honestly considered walking out, something I have never done before) and seems so confused about what exactly its trying to say that it ends up saying nothing at all. The first fictional film from documentarian Julien Donada, the film is certainly atmospheric. Unfortunately, all the expansive atmospheres and beautiful scenery serve to expose the emptiness at the films center, a hollow core which no amount of beautiful beach front cinematography can fully fill in.

Grade: C

Sunday, June 5, 2011

Beginners

By Jordan

There is a fine-line between endearingly quirky and insufferably calculated oddness (some would call this twee, but I detest the word and will myself avoid it), and this is the line on which Beginners, the new film by Mike Mills, tight-rope walks. The film is saved, when it manages to be, by its roots in the autobiographical relationship between Mills and his father. It fails, when it does, by trying too hard to be cute, subtitling a Jack Russell Terrier, creating a meet-cute styled after a silent movie due to laryngitis, and having characters steal rollerskates from a rink to glide around Los Angeles.

The film follows Mills' alter-ego Oliver (Ewan McGregor, as likable as always) as he mourns the death of his father. Through flashbacks we get to see his experiences with his dad (played superbly by Christopher Plummer) in his final years, as the 75-year-old comes out and decides to make up for lost time by being as gay as possible (wrapping himself in rainbow scarves, dancing the night away at gay clubs, writing letters of support for gay politicians and passing out gay pride stickers) and taking a younger lover Andy (a soulful yet playful Goran Visnjic). And in the present, Oliver meets Anna (Melanie Laurent, acquitting herself well in English), an equally commitment-phobic actress with diametrically opposed father issues. As we watch Oliver's relationship with his father grow as his father withers with terminal lung cancer, we also see Oliver fall for, and try to tear himself away from Anna, who may just be perfect for him. Throughout the film, all of these people struggle to decide whether to become who they want to be or to be forever restrained by their fears about the consequences of their actions.

Beginners, like its characters, is troubled because it does not know exactly what to be. Is it a carefree light romantic comedy, a tragedy-laced remembrance of a father, a weighty drama about psychological baggage, or a dramedy about human need for companionship and adaptability to new situations? In parts, it is all of these things, and its impossible not to think it would be more successful if it would simply settle on a tone and stick with it. It is never as funny as it could be, and never quite as tragic as it might be, simply floating in the middle ground between tones and never settling enough to coalesce. Beginners feels like the beginning of something great. Unfortunately that promise of greatness is never fulfilled, and we are left with the desire for a film that doesn't share its characters' flaws, a film that is more self-assured and more confident about the message it imparts.

Grade: B-

The Tree of Life

By Jordan

It took time for me to be able to even think about writing this review. It took time for me to even figure out my feelings on this movie. Those feelings are incredibly complicated, and still only half formed. I've only seen The Tree of Life once so far, though I would really like to see it again, and maybe several more times, before putting my feelings into words. So take this review with a grain of salt; consider it a report from the field, a work in progress that will only be completed in my own mind over the next several months and multiple viewings.

The Tree of Life is not a simple film, nor is it a straightforward one. It is not a perfect film, either. Yet it is a film of such mammoth scale and such startling ambition that it is hard not to see it as a cinematic masterpiece, even as I struggle to reconcile some of its flaws with its larger successes. The movie opens with a quote from the book of Job, and frames itself around a series of questions posed to a nonresponsive and possibly nonexistent God. Why do bad things happen to good people? Why does God take people from us? Where is he when all of the horrible things that happen in the world occur?

From there, the film seems to attempt to answer these questions by reaching back to the dawn of time itself in a startling, visually arresting and unforgettable sequence that recalls in style and ambition Stanley Kubrick's 2001: A Space Odyssey (and was not coincidentally developed by Douglas Trumbull, the special effects supervisor on that earlier film, who had been away from Hollywood for 30 years before returning for this film). Also working alongside the brilliant cinematographer Emmanual Lubeski (who worked on Malick's last film, The New World and on Children of Men), Malick develops a series of exalted images of the creation of the universe, the early days of our planet, and the reign of the dinosaurs before tying all of this creation back to humanity, launching forward into the twentieth century to show us the birth of a child. This portion of the film is hauntingly beautiful, aching with significance and demanding to be rewatched. It is a titanic achievement for Malick, and one the rest of the film tries, and often fails, to live up to.

The middle section of the movie is devoted to watching that child grow in mid-'50s Waco, and observing in a non-narrative, almost dream-like series of recollections the way that child, Jack, (played by the superb Hunter McCracken) is torn between the diametrically opposed philosophies of his parents, the autocratic and borderline abusive Father (Brad Pitt, in one of his best performances) and the saint-like, gently loving Mother (Jessica Chastain, who does much with very little spoken dialogue). As his mother explains in voice over, there are two ways through life: The Way of Nature, and The Way of Grace. Malick's work in archetypes may be viewed by some as simply leaving us with broadly-drawn characters; Pitt and Chastain are not multi-dimensional creations, nor are they meant to be. They represent two sides of a spectrum, with their three children being pulled in both directions simultaneously. Sean Penn appears very briefly (in a role clearly edited into almost nonexistence during post-production) as the grown Jack, who wanders in a melancholy stupor through a modern metropolis, still haunted by the suicide of his brother and by the fallout of his parents' personalities.

Malick cannot possibly top the opening hour of the film, though he often tries through the rest of its run-time. Some will call the material in Waco shapeless and lacking in narrative drive, and this is true, though the dream-like quality lends the segment a realism and a feeling of things remembered that a straightforward bildungsroman would have eschewed. And the final act, in which time itself comes to an end and we are left to contemplate eternity, feels comparatively simplistic and even banal, though it remains as beautifully shot as the rest of the film. There are definitive flaws to The Tree of Life, but there is something magnificent about its scope and ambition, which dwarves that of any other film I've seen in years. It's impossible not to see The Tree of Life as a mammoth achievement in filmmaking, and in spite of its flaws, its hard not to see this as setting the standard that every other movie this year will have to live up to. I'm betting most will fail.

Grade: A

X-Men: First Class

By Jordan

After a decade filled to the brim with comic book movies, origin stories, and reboots, X-Men: First Class has its work cut out for it. Coming after two disappointing installments in the X-Men series (2006's X-Men: The Last Stand and 2009's X-Men Origins: Wolverine), the movie had to shake things up somehow just to get audiences back in the seats. Fortunately, it does just that, moving back to the early '60's to deliver an engaging, if flawed, look at the formation of mutant-kind's last line of defense.

The film, directed by Matthew Vaughn (Kick Ass), opens just as the first X-Men did, with a young Erik Lensherr being dragged away from his mother in a concentration camp, trying in vain to bend the gate with his newly discovered super powers. He is soon taken to the sadistic Dr. Schmidt, later known as Sebastian Shaw (Kevin Bacon, having fun in the role), who uses rage to unlock the boy's powers. We are then introduced to a young Charles Xavier, who befriends a young shapeshifter named Raven.

From there the film becomes a globe-spanning trek through the early '60s, as an older Xavier (James MacAvoy) gets his doctorate as an older Erik (Michael Fassbender) seeks revenge. The two are soon drawn into the effort to recruit more mutants to counter a plot by Shaw that weaves its way into the Cuban Missile Crisis. The cast is rounded out by an incredibly game Rose Byrne as CIA Agent Moira MacTaggert, a fantastic Jennifer Lawrence as Raven, who becomes known as Mystique, and the downright awful January Jones, who stiffly stumbles through a turn as the iconic Emma Frost.

The movie is not without its flaws. All of the Cuban Missile Crisis material will feel strangely without stakes for anyone who has ever seen a better executed take on the tensions and apocalyptic fears of the period, and the sprinkling in of real life footage does more to undercut the realism than it does to serve it. The film also seems to feel the need to rush into well established moments in X-Men continuity, sacrificing what could have been an incredibly enjoyable jaunt through the early days of the team to get into developments we all know are coming. That Xavier and Lensherr will soon be arch-enemies is known by all; more fun could have been had if the film had dedicated more of its runtime to developing the bond between these two before tearing it asunder. In fact, the film is at its best during an early montage that follows the two as they attempt to recruit mutants from around the world. MacAvoy and Fassbender have an easy, realistic chemistry and crackerjack comic timing that could have been put to better use if the movie would have slowed its propulsive pace for long enough to develop more realistic character beats.

Ultimately, though, First Class achieves its ends. It is fun, fast-paced, and action packed. It keeps the tone light for much of its run time, throws in enough in jokes (and cameos) to keep fans of the series happy, and reminds any wary audience members why X-Men movies used to be so much fun. While I wish the movie hadn't felt such a strong desire to blow through as much continuity as it did, there's at least comfort in knowing that it did so with verve and aplomb. And if nothing else, it accomplished what was surely its behind the scenes goal: It got me excited for the prospect of another X-Men movie.

Grade: B+

Monday, May 23, 2011

Something to Be Excited About

We know that you loyal Review to Be Named readers have nothing to do all day but sit around waiting for us to update. We also know that we can distract you with shiny objects whenever we'd like. So here's a bauble to keep you busy for at least 20 minutes worth of replaying, the trailer for perhaps the single most anticipated movie of 2011...if you're into this sort of thing...

Sunday, April 10, 2011

Whose Film Is It Anyway?: Aaron Sorkin

By Jordan

Note: The purpose of Whose Film Is It Anyway? is to examine the validity of the auteur theory through the lens of individual film-makers, taking a look at their bodies of work and highlighting the technical elements, personal style, and thematic consistency of their films. Ultimately, the goal of this column will be to generate a discussion of the merits of auteur theory through examinations of directors widely considered auteurs, analyses of directors whose status as auteurs is more tenuous, and occasional looks at non-directors who may drive the quality and content of their films with more assuredness than the directors they work with.

“I love writing but hate starting. The page is awfully white and it says, ‘You may have fooled some of the people some of the time but those days are over, giftless. I’m not your agent and I’m not your mommy. I’m a white piece of paper, you wanna dance with me?’ And I really, really don’t.”-Aaron Sorkin

“Listen lady, a gender I write very well when the story calls for it, we make horse drawn carriages and the first Model T just rolled into town.”-Aaron Sorkin as himself, 30 Rock

When I began brainstorming this column, I honestly believed I would be able to consistently defend the idea of the screenwriter as the true author of a film. It just seemed to make sense to me that the person who wrote the actual story, the words everyone spoke, the actions everyone performed, the person who created the very conflict that drove the film, would be an arguable author of the final product. While I’ll discuss this more in depth in this column’s (temporary) conclusion next month, it turns out I was largely wrong on that front. Let’s play a little game, shall we? Name your five favorite screenwriters. I’ll simplify that even further. Name five screenwriters whose attachment to a project means you’ll absolutely see it (And no cheating and naming writer-directors either. Just the scribes, kids). My guess (and please correct me in the comments if I’m wrong) is that you had trouble putting that list together. I know I would have. Because when I hear Charlie Kaufman has written a movie, I’m there. David Mamet is pretty hit and miss, but I’ll probably tend to see his new movies when they come out unless the film in question sounds terrible or prominently features his wife Rebecca Pidgeon who makes me want to gouge out my eyes and ears and throw heavy things at the screen until she goes away. Beyond those two, only one writer will send me running for the theater on opening day: Aaron Sorkin.

This is a film column by nature, and so I will focus on Sorkin’s movies to make my point, but it would be silly for me to gloss over Sorkin’s television career in a discussion of his status as the author of his works. Television, as a rule, is written by a variety of writers on a rotation to ensure there is no delay in the production schedule. Even most of the television shows you associate with one show runner are usually written by a variety of people. David Simon is the brains behind The Wire and received story credit on all but ten episodes, yet he only wrote the teleplays for 20 of the show’s 60 episodes. David Chase is the heart and soul of The Sopranos and was involved in all of the writing, but he only wrote the full script for 30 of the show’s 86 episodes. Joss Whedon wrote only 24 of Buffy’s 144 episodes, Alan Ball wrote only 9 of Six Feet Under’s 60 episodes, and Larry David wrote 62 of Seinfeld’s 180 episodes. By contrast, Aaron Sorkin wrote or co-wrote 40 of the 45 episodes of Sports Night, wrote or co-wrote 86 of the 89 episodes of The West Wing before he was fired, and every single one of Studio 60’s 22 episodes. When Aaron Sorkin is the name on a television show, you can bet the farm that he’ll be writing pretty much every episode, crafting the arcs, character development, dialogue, and, since he handpicks the directors of his shows, and generally uses Thomas Schlamme, has a hand in their direction as well.





But we aren’t here to talk about Sorkin’s television career, where he is surely the master of his domain. Sorkin has turned in scripts for five movies over the last two decades, and each bears his mark so strongly, it is impossible not to think of them as Aaron Sorkin films. Even when Sorkin works with strong directors who may themselves be considered auteurs, he manages to make each and every one of his films his own, filled to the brim with his signature witty repartee, hyper-literate references, passionate idealism and focus on committed professionals.

His first screenplay was based off of his own play, and directed by Rob Reiner. A Few Good Men follows a lazy and inexperienced lawyer (Tom Cruise) who becomes a passionate advocate when he is required to defend two soldiers accused of killing a fellow recruit during a hazing ritual. With the help of his best friend (Kevin Pollack) and another investigator (Demi Moore), he manages to make his case that his clients were just following the orders of base commander Colonel Nathan Jessup (Jack Nicholson, who was nominated for Best Supporting Actor for his tour de force performance). Despite working under the very experienced Reiner, there is no doubt that Sorkin’s influence shines through the strongest. From the lightning quick banter to the passionate idealism of the characters and their strong dedication to doing their jobs, it is clear that the script took center stage during the filming process.



Sorkin’s next big project had him teamed with Rob Reiner once again for the political romantic comedy The American President. Often referred to as Sorkin’s “test balloon” for The West Wing, Reiner helped Sorkin get the film produced to prove the viability of a television show about the president of the united states, which Sorkin would finally bring to television four years later. The film follows widowed President Andrew Shepherd (Michael Douglas) as he struggles to maintain a relationship with a lobbyist (Annette Bening) while passing a crime bill that will consolidate his approval rating before his reelection campaign. The film is clearly a blueprint for the series to come, and the two share plotlines, dialogue, and even cast members (Martin Sheen plays the Chief of Staff in the film and President Bartlet on the show, and five other cast members from the film played roles on the series). From the film’s inception to its release, this was Sorkin’s project, with Reiner agreeing to direct only to ensure the film would be produced and released by a studio.



Over a decade later, Sorkin returned to film with Charlie Wilson’s War, which paired him with directorial titan Mike Nichols as he adapted the book by George Crile. Congressman Charlie Wilson (Tom Hanks) is more partier than politician until his friend and sometimes lover Joanne Herring (Julia Roberts) convinces him he has to help the Afghan people in their struggle against the Soviets. Wilson befriends CIA Agent Gust Avrakotos (Oscar nominated Phillip Seymour Hoffman) and becomes a passionate advocate for arming the people of Afghanistan. While the film is clearly a Mike Nichols movie, Sorkin’s influence permeates every scene, from the similarities between Wilson’s development and the development of Tom Cruise’s character in A Few Good Men to the ideologies espoused throughout the film. Rumors have surfaced that the ending of Sorkin’s screenplay differs majorly from the ending of the film, which gives Charlie Wilson a happy ending and avoids directly referencing the 9/11 attacks. According to sources from the set, Tom Hanks demanded that the ending be altered and Nichols and Sorkin complied, though neither was happy with the change.



Perhaps the most fascinating pairing of writer to director in his career, last year’s The Social Network, which finally won Sorkin Best Adapted Screenplay, paired Sorkin with the incredibly distinctive David Fincher. While the film does play with Fincher’s pet themes about obsession, power, and the dark side of the human soul, Sorkin’s dialogue and predilection for characters who are addicted to their work above all else shine through just as strongly. Mark Zuckerberg (Jess Eisenberg, nominated for Best Actor for the role) somehow manages to be both a stock Fincher and Sorkin protagonist, making him a fascinating study of the dark side of dedication and the isolation of intelligence and arrogance. When I first heard that Sorkin and Fincher were teaming up for The Social Network, I wasn’t sure how the combination of two consistently strong visions would work out, yet the film is a complete triumph, giving us the best of both men’s work in one two hour tour de force.



The script for The Social Network is so completely engrossing and enjoyable, I actually found myself continually hoping the film would never end. While Fincher’s work on the movie is incredible (and, if I ever get around to covering Fincher for this column, his work will be examined and praised even more closely), it is Sorkin’s gift for dialogue that lifts the movie into the stratosphere, giving it easily the best script of last year. The conflicts spark with such verbal vitriol it is actually pulse-poundingly tense just to watch the characters sit across a deposition table from each other, so dynamic that even their discussions of intellectual property sizzle with multiple meanings, sarcasm, and subtle character developments.



As Sorkin playfully warned during his recent cameo on 30 Rock, the importance of the writer in Hollywood is constantly in danger of sliding toward irrelevance, yet the strength of a few great writers is enough to remind the skeptical of the importance of the written word. When examining one of the movies written by Aaron Sorkin, or any of the television series he has written, his influence on their quality is clear. He is a constant reminder that without a great script, it is difficult to make a great movie, and each of Sorkin’s always excellent screenplays makes the movie truly, meaningfully his, even when he has to compete with some of the greatest auteurs of our age for the privilege of saying so.

Read more Whose Film Is It Anyway? here

Coming up on Whose Film Is It Anyway?:

Note: Whose Film Is It Anyway? will go on indefinite hiatus after these final two installments.

4/24: Christopher Nolan

5/8: Notes on the Auteur Theory in 2011

Want to keep tabs on all of our updates? follow us on twitter @reviewtobenamed (follow us here).

Sunday, March 27, 2011

Whose Film Is It Anyway?: Michael Bay

By Jordan

Note: The purpose of Whose Film Is It Anyway? is to examine the validity of the auteur theory through the lens of individual film-makers, taking a look at their bodies of work and highlighting the technical elements, personal style, and thematic consistency of their films. Ultimately, the goal of this column will be to generate a discussion of the merits of auteur theory through examinations of directors widely considered auteurs, analyses of directors whose status as auteurs is more tenuous, and occasional looks at non-directors who may drive the quality and content of their films with more assuredness than the directors they work with.

“I know you’re new to the whole human experience, but there is one universal truth: you never give a woman your credit card!”-James McCord (Steve Buscemi), The Island

Michael Bay is a name not to be thrown out likely in circles of cinephiles. Widely disliked, and occasionally passionately despised, he is a director serious movie fans prefer to either dismiss or deride. In fact, I have often heard news of the commercial success of one of his films heralded as a sign of the end times of film as an artistic form. I did not choose to do a column on Michael Bay because I like his movies (that is certainly not the case), nor did I make the decision lightly. Some of his movies run nearly three hours, and, especially in the case of Pearl Harbor, that can be a torturous experience. I wanted to do a column on him in an effort to make a point about the auteur theory I don’t think I’ve communicated so far: it does not take quality into account. A director is called an auteur not because they make consistently good films, but that they make films that are consistent. In fact, in the early days of the theory, it was a common practice to examine a director’s worst films to see if the technical elements, personal flourishes, and thematic concerns remained consistent even if the film wasn’t very good. And so, in a flurry of masochism and to illustrate the point as best I know how, I have undertaken to peer beneath the smooth, shapeless veneer of Michael Bay’s films and examine them for the consistency that would be required to call the man, easily among my least favorite directors, an auteur.

I want to look at three aspects of his films, all shockingly easy to identify if you’ve watched any or all of them, and from those make the argument that Michael Bay should be considered an auteur, even though he should also be considered a manipulative, shallow, childish and misogynistic hack. That last point is probably as good a place as any to begin our examination of Bay as an auteur. For a man that traffics in blockbusters packed with gorgeous women and what I’m sure he would call “sexually charged situations,” Bay is surprisingly, even disconcertingly timid about the down and dirty practice of (dare I say it?) the sex. To Michael Bay, women never seem to become actual characters with actual motivations. In one of his films, women are objects: you can ogle them, sure, but you aren’t really supposed to have sex with them.

This is laid out very clearly in the Bad Boys series. The first one has Tea Leoni, whose best friend is a hooker she accompanies on a job and sees murdered (perhaps because she engages in the most shameful practice in a Michael Bay film), in a constant parade of shockingly short skirts and high heels. Objectified to an insulting degree throughout the movie, Leoni never actually has sex in the film. In fact, no one does. It is constantly referred to that Will Smith’s Mike Lowery has a lot of sex and is a total playboy (because that means he’s cool, right?) but we never see him have sex, nor is it implied that he has any during the movie. And his partner Marcus Burnett (Martin Lawrence) just complains for the whole run time about how his wife never has sex with him. Burnett’s wife is one of my least favorite cinematic tropes (and one I have ranted about before), the shrewish wife who is so horrible to her husband there is no way he would ever stay married to her. Not only does she withhold sex from him, she does it because he has to work late. In Bay’s view, women are there to get in the way of you doing cool shit with your bros, not to actually have a real relationship with.





In Bad Boys II, super-player Mike Lowery has an actual girlfriend Syd (Gabrielle Union) but seems to only want to make out with her. And even that is too much for his partner, who just happens to be Syd’s brother. A subplot of the film is how angry Marcus gets at Mike for dating his sister. Fortunately, by the end of the movie he has made peace with the incredibly chaste relationship. This trend is almost perfectly exemplified by a scene in Bad Boys II where our heroes admire a dead woman’s fake breasts. The only nudity you will see in a Michael Bay film comes removed from any worry that you might actually have to have sex afterwards. The only time the two characters seem to be comfortable discussing breasts is once the woman possessing them is dead and they can be lewd over her corpse.



Whether they are pregnant wives left to worry about their adventurous husbands, like Vanessa Marcil in The Rock, sheltered daughters torn between their love for Dad and their desire to actually have an adult relationship like Liv Tyler in Armageddon (she’s also left on Earth while the men, and one shockingly de-sexualized woman go to blow up the big asteroid), or stuck doing a “woman’s job” like nursing until they get knocked up by a protagonist like Kate Beckinsale in Pearl Harbor, the women in Bay’s films are caricatures at best, and objects the rest of the time.



Michael Bay deals with relationships like he’s a 14-year-old boy guessing what they might be. He’s too horny to deal with women as actual people, so the idea of them as naked objects takes over, but he’s also too immature to have put thought into what he might actually do if a willing girl showed up naked on his doorstep. Girls are still things of fantasy; dealing with them as sexual beings in and of themselves is uncomfortable if not just icky. Bay may be most like Lincoln Six Echo, Ewan McGregor’s character from The Island. He likes Scarlett Johansson obviously and from the very beginning, but because he’s a clone, his sex drive and knowledge of the act has been completely removed, so his attraction to her remains stunted and chaste for most of the film’s run time. He literally doesn’t know what sex is, which seems to be the best position for a Bay protagonist to be in (to be fair, McGregor and Johansson do actually have sex by the film’s end, but only right before he leaves her to go blow up some shit, in spite of the fact that she is a better fighter).



There is a slight shift in this in Bay’s last two movies, the first two installments in the probably endless Transformers series. Megan Fox actually gets to fight giant robots, date Shia LaBeouf (apparently she wants that), and care about being in an adult relationship (though by the definitions of the film, that means she wants LaBeouf to say “I love you”). As a counter balance to this nebulous progress, though, she is objectified far more than any other female lead, from being bent over the hood of a car in the first film to being even more bent over a motor cycle in the second one. I could probably write the rest of this column on the downright creepy state of arrested development Bay seems caught in when it comes to relationships, but instead, let’s look at some other signs of his stunted growth.





Michael Bay, like many a rebellious teenage boy, has trouble with authority figures. In Bad Boys, its internal affairs, who apparently wants to investigate our heroes for some vague and never really defined reason. Because this is a Michael Bay movie, the investigation never goes anywhere and what would be investigated is never really defined, but that isn’t really the point. Bay’s movies don’t have plots so much as they have some idea what a plot should look like; they are less concerned with conflict than with the fact that if somebody doesn’t start shooting at somebody soon, things might get boring. And if there’s one thing Bay never wants, it’s for a movie of his to get boring.



In The Rock, the whole plot is set in motion because Ed Harris’ army man decides to take over Alcatraz and hold San Francisco hostage in order to extort the government out of money they didn’t pay to the families of soldiers who died on black ops missions. Sure, Ed Harris takes 80 hostages and threatens to release biological weapons on a huge city to get what he wants, but this is only because Uncle Sam and all the greedy politicians in Washington refused to pay money to the families of dead soldiers. So who is really the bad guy? Also, John Mason (Sean Connery), the man who has the knowledge of Alcatraz needed to stop Harris, is a British spy illegally detained by the government because he knew too much.



In Armageddon, the only reason the world isn’t completely destroyed is because Bay’s heroes are a rag tag bunch of criminals and misfits who just won’t follow the rules, man. At one point, the President orders some general (Keith David, always fun to have around) to detonate the nuke on the asteroid, in spite of the fact that every scientist in the room is saying that will only kill everyone they sent up there and then ensure the destruction of mankind. Fortunately, head of NASA Billy Bob Thornton is a rebel who cuts communications to keep the bomb from detonating. Later, leader of the drill team Harry Stamper (Bruce Willis) has to strangle the shuttle’s pilot (William Fitchner) for a while to keep him from blowing everybody up. The government, in Bay’s view, is full of selfish and stupid bureaucrats who will ruin everyone’s fun unless they are stopped. Even in Pearl Harbor where Bay has to go easy on the government because he’s constrained by reality, the polio-stricken and wheelchair bound Roosevelt has to literally stand up to force his cabinet to realize the severity of the attack.



The final tendency I want to discuss probably seems obvious, yet still needs to be laid out as a consistent aspect of Bay’s films: the “more is always better” approach he takes to making them. One can say a lot of terrible things about Bay’s movies, and I have, but the charge it is most difficult to levy against him is that his movies are boring (with the exception of Pearl Harbor, because Jesus that movie is long and boring). His movies are over-stuffed with action to the point of sheer gluttony. The Island plays out like a two hour long chase scene, with barely enough time for exposition between all of the car chases and exploding helicopters. Before things even really get going in The Rock (which is my pick, if forced, for Bay’s best movie, a nearly meaningless distinction akin to picking out the rotting food that tastes the best) we have an attack on a military base, a bomb scare, and an insane and ridiculously long car chase through the streets of San Francisco that has so little to do with the actual plot, it might have been thrown in there because Bay realized the movie would be too short without it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5-PCs8V7nLg



Michael Bay is so successful, in my estimation, not because he makes good movies (he clearly doesn’t) but because he makes consistent movies. When a Michael Bay movie is released, if you go to see it you know exactly what you’ll get. You know there won’t be any plot to speak of, sure, but you also know you’ll see scantily clad women, gun fights, car chases, and explosions. And perhaps just as importantly, you know you’ll see A LOT of all of that. Bay makes terrible movies, and though I’ve never met the man personally, an analysis of his work tells me he’s probably not a great human being. He’s immature, simplistic, misogynistic, shallow, and by all measures, a hack but his movies are absolutely and completely his. The mind behind Armageddon, Bad Boys, The Island, and Transformers may be a simple one, but what it puts up on the screens is a personal expression, whether we like it or not. Michael Bay’s movies have personality, even though that personality is one that I fervently dislike and wish didn’t exist. I don’t love any of his movies (though I can definitely say that some are more enjoyable than others), but I see why so many people do. You know what you’re going to get when you see a Michael Bay movie, and he delivers it so consistently, it is impossible not to consider the man an auteur.

Read more Whose Film Is It Anyway? here

Coming up on Who's Film Is It Anyway?:

Note: Whose Film Is It Anyway? will go on indefinite hiatus after these final three installments.

4/10:Aaron Sorkin

4/24: Christopher Nolan

5/8: Notes on the Auteur Theory in 2011

Want to keep tabs on all of our updates? follow us on twitter @reviewtobenamed (follow us here).

Monday, March 14, 2011

Whose Film Is It Anyway?: Hal Ashby

By Jordan

Note: The purpose of Whose Film Is It Anyway? is to examine the validity of the auteur theory through the lens of individual film-makers, taking a look at their bodies of work and highlighting the technical elements, personal style, and thematic consistency of their films. Ultimately, the goal of this column will be to generate a discussion of the merits of auteur theory through examinations of directors widely considered auteurs, analyses of directors whose status as auteurs is more tenuous, and occasional looks at non-directors who may drive the quality and content of their films with more assuredness than the directors they work with.

“I like to watch.”-Chance the Gardener (Peter Sellers), Being There

Often when writing this column, I find myself making arguments for a director’s status as an auteur, even when I was prepared initially to disregard him or her as something less when I first approached their work. James Cameron, for example, is someone in whose work I expected to find little consistency, yet by the time I sat down to write the column, it seemed impossible not to at least make an argument for recurring themes and techniques (and many jokes about his insane richness). One of the best things about writing Whose Film Is It Anyway? has been getting the chance to fill in some cinematic blind spots. Whether watching movies by a director whose work I had never seen before or getting the chance to see some of the movies I’d previously missed from a director I already loved, the column has constantly expanded my cinematic horizons and changed my understanding of film.

I am getting ahead of myself with this retrospective, to be sure, and you can look for a lot more like this when this column reaches its (temporary) end in May, yet I bring all of this up by way of introduction for the director we will be examining this week: Hal Ashby. When I was preparing this column, filling my Netflix queue with Ashby’s work, I had already seen two of his movies, Harold and Maude and Being There, and the strength of those was enough to have me excited for what was to come. Having now seen over half of his movies, I can say with some confidence that I wasn’t missing much. Not only did I not enjoy most of his films all that much, I found very little connective tissue between his works. As I said above, I can usually at least mount an argument for a director’s thematic consistency if I look hard enough, yet Ashby offered precious little by way of constancy. The closest I can come to finding a pet theme is his depiction of male sexuality in both its destructive and redemptive forms, but even that seems more like an accident of the times he was working than a dedicated examination by an artist fully in control of his works.

Ashby leaps from theme to theme and from technical style to technical style so fluidly he almost perfectly encapsulates a chameleon behind the camera. From one perspective that can be seen as a talent, and indeed, some might argue that a director putting his personal stamp on his films is just getting in the way of the art. Yet this column is dedicated to the idea that a director is the author of his films, and to date Ashby may be the best argument I’ve found in a director against the auteur theory. To be fair, the theory does not presuppose that every director is an auteur, nor that they should all be considered as such. Ashby lacks the thematic stability, technical style and personal touch required to deem one an auteur, and whether because of this or in spite of it, he often stumbled on his way to making great films.

After spending years working odd jobs around Hollywood, Ashby gained recognition when he won the Oscar for Best Editing for In the Heat of the Night. Leveraging this success into his debut film as a director, Ashby stuck to what had worked for him on that film, examining race relations in America during the period in The Landlord. Widely heralded as a topical “film of its time,” The Landlord follows Elgar Enders (Beau Bridges) as he buys a tenement in Park Slope, Brooklyn with the intent of evicting all of its residents, until he gains affection for the poverty stricken black residents there and rebels against his WASP roots. The film works well enough as an examination of racial attitudes in the late ‘60s, but viewed apart from its political impact, it is poorly paced and often dull. In a recent New York Times article on the movie entitled “Before Gentrification was Cool, It was a Movie,” Mike Hale praised the film for tackling the racial tension ensuing after the death of Martin Luther King Jr. and mentioned that the movie “[…] would disappear after its 1970 release—rarely shown and just as rarely discussed.” At the risk of over-reliance on my critical faculties, I would like to theorize that the film is rarely seen and discussed for no more surprising reason than that it isn’t very good.



Ashby followed up The Landlord with a movie that is so much better it’s hard to even compare the two. Harold and Maude follows the death obsessed young protagonist (Bud Cort) as he meets and becomes enchanted by the elderly Maude (an excellent Ruth Gordon) who teaches him to appreciate his life. The film operates at a level of whimsy that leaves the rest of Asbhy’s work far behind (and always seems to me like a very obvious influence on the work of Wes Anderson) and features an early example of the Manic Pixie Dream girl (and quite possible the oldest incarnation of said character, seeing as Maude is nearing 80 throughout the film), yet it is somehow played with just the right mixture of cloying cuteness and pitch black humor to ensure that it never (ok, rarely) goes over the top. Backed by an excellent soundtrack from Cat Stevens and filled with earned emotions that transcend the “of the times” feel of his previous film, Harold and Maude manages to be a very good film almost in spite of Ashby’s lackluster direction. Roger Ebert, in an incredibly negative review, directly criticized Ashby, saying, “The visual style makes everyone look fresh from the wax museum…” and while I disagree with many of his points about the film, he isn’t wrong here. In a movie that manages to be sweet when by all accounts it should feel saccharine, the direction is easily the film’s weakest point.



After trying on the timely film and a flight of fancy, Ashby moved on to The Last Detail, a dramedy about two Navy sailors, Billy “badass” Buddusky (an Oscar nominated Jack Nicholson) and “Mule” Mulhall (Otis Young) who are assigned to escort Larry Meadows (Randy Quaid, nominated for Best Supporting Actor for the role) to Naval Prison, where he will serve a term of eight years for petty larceny. Along the way, the sailors decide to show Meadows a good time to make up for his unjust sentence, and tomfoolery ensues. Also nominated for Best Adapted Screenplay, The Last Detail can hardly be called a failure, yet again, Ashby’s direction is the lowpoint. Where in Harold and Maude he managed to make everything look about three shades more drab than necessary to make his point, here it appears almost as if he has no point: perhaps this is the movie that taught Kevin Smith how to direct, as the camera, more often than not, is just pointed in a direction likely to capture the action and left alone thereafter.



Ashby next directed Shampoo, a sexual farce that remembers it’s a satire occasionally, but often forgets to add the humor. The film follows George Roundy (Warren Beatty) a Beverly Hills hairdresser who gets around like Don Draper without the charm of the alcohol problems. Set on the eve of the election of Richard Nixon (and released after Watergate had been revealed, giving the film a sense that its setting should mean something, when it is mostly used to give the proceedings the vaguest hint of irony), the film follows George as he tries to avoid settling down with his girlfriend Jill (Goldie Hawn), uses his mistress Felicia (Lee Grant) for access to her wealthy husband Lester (Jack Warden), and then realizes his true love is his ex-girlfriend and Lester’s current mistress Jackie (Julie Christie). It all sounds a great deal more complex and interesting than it appears in execution.



Moving ever forward toward completely different material, Ashby next directed the Woody Guthrie biopic Bound for Glory, notable only for being the first film to utilize Steadicam technology. If you’re thinking that this is an indication of Ashby’s technical capabilities, think again: the Steadicam was invented by cinematographer Garret Brown, who, in association with Director of Photography Haskell Wexler (who won Best Cinematography for his work) gave the film its occasionally dynamic visual style. Bound for Glory is a movie you should see for one of three reasons: 1. You are enough of a film geek to care about the first use of Steadicam, 2. You really love the music of Woody Guthrie, or 3. You are desperately curious what a young David Carradine (who plays Guthrie) looks like. Spoiler alert: he looks a lot like old David Carradine.



Ashby’s greatest film, and the only one for which I can argue his unassuming visual style actually improves the work, is 1979’s Being There. The movie is an arch satire of the self-centered obliviousness of people in power, following a mentally handicapped gardener named Chance (Oscar nominated Peter Sellers in perhaps his best performance) who is cast out of the only home he’s ever known when his previous employer dies. Chance wanders the city until he is hit by a wealthy socialite Eve Rand (Shirley MacClaine) and brought back to her mansion to recover. There, the obliviousness of those around him leaves him mistaken as a wealthy businessman named Chauncey Gardiner, whose simple statements about gardening are often mistaken for wise and insightful allegories about business and life. Chance becomes close with Eve’s wealthy and seriously ill husband Ben (Best Supporting Actor winner Melvyn Douglas), and eventually the President of the United States (Jack Warden) all along the way to accidentally becoming a prominent and well respected member of the American elite. Being There is brilliant, hilarious, and insightful, and Ashby’s simple style actually seems to mirror the way that Chance views the world (though, like his protagonist, I am now left wondering if Ashby stumbled into directing an excellent film because his already unassuming style happened to fit it perfectly).



Following Being There, Ashby fell out of favor in Hollywood, making several more films but receiving little critical attention before his death in 1986. Generally it is fairly easy to determine how well-directed a movie is, yet with Ashby behind the camera, I am often left wondering if any of my favorite directorial moments are actually done with purposefully or if Ashby found his best film by accidentally making one that closely mirrored his style. It would be impossible to call Hal Ashby an auteur, and indeed, even calling him a good director often seems like a stretch. Yet Ashby managed to make two movies I love and happened to be in charge when several other people turned in excellent work, whether it be actors, writers, or cinematographers. Perhaps Hal Ashby’s greatest contribution to film wasn’t Being There. It’s possible, in fact, that his greatest accomplishment was just being there.


Read more Whose Film Is It Anyway? here

Coming up on Who's Film Is It Anyway?:

3/27: Michael Bay

4/10:Aaron Sorkin

4/24: Christopher Nolan

5/8: Notes on the Auteur Theory in 2011

Want to keep tabs on all of our updates? follow us on twitter @reviewtobenamed (follow us here).

Friday, March 11, 2011

Random Pop Culture Question of the Week: Erasing Movies From an Entertainer's Career

Random Pop Culture Question of the Week is a bi-weekly journey into the headspace of the Review to Be Named gang, in which a pop-culture question is posed, answers are sought, and discussions are generated about issues and hypotheticals from throughout the realm of pop culture.

This week’s question comes from our own Rachel, who asked,
Hypothetically speaking, if the movies Gods came to you and gave you the opportunity to act as a temporary savior for your favorite star (or director) what role/production would you remove from their career and why?
With that question in mind, here are the responses from several Review to Be Named contributors. Comment and let us know what we missed!

Sam:

When thinking about this hypothetical there was a wealth of options to choose from. My first reaction was to remove ugly performances/projects from the career of some of my favorite filmmakers and actors. Do I remove the Apebraham Lincoln stain from Tim Burton’s career thanks to Planet of the Apes? Or do I try to salvage some respect for our greatest actors worst money-grubbing roles like Jack Nicholson’s Anger Management or Dustin Hoffman’s Mr. Magorium’s Wonder Emporium? But what I settled on was erasing a movie I actually love. I wish that Terry Gilliam’s The Adventures of Baron Munchausen just never happened. It’s a great film that shows off what Gilliam does best. Fantastical and unapologetically wacky, it is the prototypical Terry Gilliam movie that praises the power of storytelling and cinematic fun. But the reason that I would love this film to be wiped from the collective memories of everyone on the planet has to do with the horrific production story that came with Munchausen. The movie was a financial disaster that basically put a giant WARNING label on everything Gilliam would make to this day. Terry Gilliam is now a pariah of sorts in the Hollywood community, fighting to finance his always-ambitious projects. Remember those first, bland as rice cake, Harry Potter films? Well, Terry could have spiced those up had he not scared the crap out of every major studio head. Didn’t like Zack Snyder’s style over substance Watchmen film? Maybe Terry could have made the only Alan Moore approved film (or television series) to ever be released. Lastly, Gilliam’s pet project, The Man Who Killed Don Quixote has been marred with production issues for years. He’s been forced to seek purely European funding (which he set a record for and still was miles behind most Hollywood budgets) for a movie that is just too ambitious [cursed by voodoo movie spirits] for a glorious release. Sorry Terry, I love Baron Munchausen as much as the next nerd, but I’m doing it for the good of your fans everywhere.


Jordan:

This was a really god damn hard question, Rachel. First off, I knew I wasn’t going to do an actor, because I can always rationalize that they did it for the money or for the role (there are certain roles that I think you take, regardless of the quality. If they offer you Batman, George Clooney, you get a pass for taking the role.) My first thought, like Sam’s, was removing Planet of the Apes from Tim Burton’s career, but on second thought, he made a good movie after that (Big Fish ranks among his best in my mind) and I don’t think erasing that would stop the quality free-fall he’s been in for the last several years. He may just be beyond saving.

Even the worst movies by some of my favorite directors aren’t that bad. I could erase The Ladykillers or Intolerable Cruelty from the Coen Brothers oeuvre, but neither of those movies are as bad as their reputation, and I really like that the Coens get a movie out pretty much every year. I hated Gangs of New York, but I can’t really fault Scorsese for making it, and Daniel Day Lewis is pretty great in it. I think its tough to pin point the movie that started Woody Allen’s downslide, and I’m not sure erasing it would save him.

Finally, I thought about erasing Elizabethtown, which promptly ended my love affair with Cameron Crowe, who made one of my favorite movies of the last decade, Almost Famous, and also made Vanilla Sky, a pretty solid remake of Abres los Ojos. But his follow up, We Built a Zoo is yet to hit theaters, and I fear I may be erasing Elizabethtown without saving him from falling into an endless well of whimsy, Manic Pixie Dream Girls, and awfulness. So I’m going to throw myself on the filmic cross to erase a movie that I think might actually have a grand effect on cinematic history. At the risk of futility, I’m going to erase Star Wars: Episode I: The Phantom Menace. Ideally, this would stop Lucas from making the entire disastrous trilogy and preserve the legacy of the Original Trilogy. Hell, if he wasn’t planning Phantom Menace, there’s even a chance he wouldn’t have done those terrible re-releases in the late ‘90s (Greedo shoots first? Really?). I’ve already talked at length about my theory of Lucas’ artistic death, but if I could stop him from shitting on his own legacy and crushing the dreams of legions of fanboys, it would mean that people could mention Star Wars without saying “but...” And even if he still made another trilogy of Star Wars movies, and still messed with the originals, I at least would have spared the world Jar Jar Binks. Which is good enough for me.

Chris:

Swept Away. I’ve never seen Swept Away. I never intend to see Swept Away. I only know that it marred the otherwise genius streak of Guy Ritchie’s fun crime thrillers that include Lock, Stock, and Two Smoking Barrels, Snatch, and RockNRolla. Is Ritchie kind of repetitive and formulaic when it comes to plotting? Yes. However when you do your niche that well, an argument can be made for not deviating from it. And that argument is Swept Away.

Rachel:

Ok listen. I’m probably going to catch a lot of crap for this, but I’m going to go with it anyway. Because the boys are entirely too serious to consider an actor for this question, and I like to think I bring this whole operation a much needed dose of the low brow.

James Franco. I love him. In my eyes, he can do very little wrong. He’s stupid pretty (duh), he’s getting a PhD in English (swoon), and he’s made it clear recently that he (shock and awe) knows how to read, and that he does it often. Unfortunately, he’s taken a lot of really, really shitty roles. I can explain away the stint on General Hospital as a giant fuck you to Hollywood and an uber-meta piece of performance art (in the show he plays a performance artist, and Franco is a fledgling performance artist, and the cycle goes on and on and on until my head explodes). But he was an absolutely exquisite Allen Ginsberg, I adored him in Milk, and I cannot wait to see him as Hart Crane.

My love for Franco is relatively new, and as a convert, I refuse to hold him all that accountable for the shit that actors need to wade through when they’re getting started. It would be like an ex-post facto judgment and, as a former Constitution nerd, I’m just not down with that. But I have absolutely no qualms about criticizing him for contemporary roles. And I have only three words to levy a major criticism against my new obsession:

Eat .Pray. Love.

Generally, I wouldn’t mind if this atrocious, sappy, pointless movie was erased forever and I could forget that a slew of actors I liked stuck their hands into this cesspool. But the one that hits the hardest is Franco.

Why, James? Just why? Why subjugate yourself to a piece of fluffy (albeit tasty) man candy? I’ve come to expect more from you. And your fruit loop of a character was honestly barely redeemable (although definitely the best of all the men in the movie, except maybe for Billy Crudup’s character, whose only crime was wanting to go back to school, something I can really never fault anyone for). But when your competition is a super obnoxious Julia Roberts and a crybaby Javier Bardem, being the lesser of the evils isn’t really saying much. My love (sometimes, and at least for movie stars) is largely contingent on their ability to maintain artistic integrity. And nothing about Eat Pray Love says integrity.

Stick to the meaty roles, James. Because if you keep taking this shit, I’m going to have to re-allot my time from justifying your enigmatic Twitter behavior, and really, neither of us can afford that.

Read more Random Pop Culture Question of the Week here

Got ideas for future installments of Random Pop Culture Question of the Week? Well let us know! Follow us on twitter @reviewtobenamed (follow us here), or shoot us an e-mail at reviewtobenamed@gmail.com.

Sunday, February 27, 2011

Whose Film Is It Anyway?: Quentin Tarantino

By Jordan

Note: The purpose of Whose Film Is It Anyway? is to examine the validity of the auteur theory through the lens of individual film-makers, taking a look at their bodies of work and highlighting the technical elements, personal style, and thematic consistency of their films. Ultimately, the goal of this column will be to generate a discussion of the merits of auteur theory through examinations of directors widely considered auteurs, analyses of directors whose status as auteurs is more tenuous, and occasional looks at non-directors who may drive the quality and content of their films with more assuredness than the directors they work with.

“The violent intensity of Pulp Fiction calls to mind other violent watershed films that were considered classics in their time and still are. Hitchcock's Psycho [1960], Arthur Penn's Bonnie and Clyde [1967], and Stanley Kubrick's A Clockwork Orange [1971]. Each film shook up a tired, bloated movie industry and used a world of lively lowlifes to reflect how dull other movies had become. And that, I predict, will be the ultimate honor for Pulp Fiction. Like all great films, it criticizes other movies.”-Gene Siskel

“I steal from every movie ever made.”-Quentin Tarantino

In the 1970’s, widely considered the best decade in cinema, a wave of directors appeared on the scene who changed everything. Quickly gaining great freedom in Hollywood to make movies that fit with their own personal views and pet themes (this was helped by the death knells of the traditional studio system), this generation of directors, this batch of auteurs, are collectively known as the film school brats. Scorsese, Coppola,Lucas, Spielberg and several others emerged from film schools in the late ‘60s and by the early ‘70s were making movies that permanently changed the face of cinema. However, there is a law of physics that tells us for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction, and while this column doesn’t set out to make the argument that this always holds true in Hollywood, I think there is a certain potency in the view that the video store brats of the early 1990’s can be seen as the equal and opposite reaction to the film school brats. Robert Rodriguez, Allison Anders, and Kevin Smith are all members of this cadre. Yet the reason the video store brats can even be counted within the same league as the film school brats is a pretty simple one. It’s because the most acclaimed of the video store brats is Quentin Tarantino.

There is an argument to be made that Tarantino has influenced film in the last two decades more than any other single director. Think of all of the Tarantino-lite fare that has been released since Pulp Fiction. Most of the Tarantino “inspired” movies are little more than rehashes of his style that ape his pop-culture hyper-literacy, banter heavy dialogue, and ultra-violence. I can’t imagine Tarantino minds this phenomenon too much, though, as he freely admits that all of his own movies are giant homages to the films and the genres that he loves.

Tarantino’s first film, Reservoir Dogs, was widely seen as a sea change in American cinema. At the time of its release, Jami Bernard of the New York Daily News compared it to L’Arrive d’un Train en Gare de la Ciotat, the 1895 film that depicted a train coming at the camera and lead audiences to scream and scatter in fear. In short, he said, “I don’t think people were ready for it.” His use of non-linear storytelling, strong language and graphic violence shocked viewers and raised expectations immeasurably for the quality and verve of independent cinema. The film follows the planning and botched execution of a diamond heist by six “nameless” criminals, using colors as aliases, a crime lord (Lawrence Tierney), and his rough edged son Eddie (Chris Penn). After a brief introduction to the gang as they eat breakfast before pulling the job, the film leaps immediately to the bloody aftermath, with Mr. Orange (Tim Roth) gutshot in the backseat of a car being driven by the sympathetic Mr. White (Harvey Keitel). The two head to a safehouse, where they are joined by the paranoid Mr. Pink (Steve Buscemi) who believes that one of them is a rat. As the men try to determine who among their numbers betrayed them, the film jumps back and forth to the formation of the group, the planning of the heist, and the histories of some of the people involved.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=awGkBWTlZPE&feature=fvwrel

Heralded as blazingly original and the arrival of a completely unique cinematic voice at the time of its release, Tarantino quickly, and often, rattled off numerous influences to the film that shaped the characters, the style, and the story. He says it was most directly influenced by Stanley Kubrick’s The Killing, calling Reservoir Dogs, “…my Killing, my take on that kind of heist movie.” Tarantino has also listed Kansas City Confidential (in which an undercover cop has infiltrated a heist), The Big Combo (in which a cop is tortured while tied to a chair), and the original version of The Taking of Pelham One Two Three (in which the people involved in the crime name themselves after colors to preserve anonymity). The title is also theorized to be a reference to Louis Malle’s Au Revoir Les Enfants and to Sam Peckinpah’s Straw Dogs. In spite of all its filmic antecedents, Reservoir Dogs is still completely infused with Tarantino’s flourishes, from the banter between the characters to the ‘70s heavy soundtrack, and manages to be a film that is in many ways greater than the sum of its parts.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=monNMsQyfCE&feature=related

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9mCfzQOyANk&feature=fvwrel

While showing Reservoir Dogs at a variety of European film festivals, Tarantino began work on his next screenplay, which he hoped would be a movie version of the hardboiled crime fiction magazine Black Mask, aiming to tell three stories that would fit into the crime fiction genre with a hardboiled pulp feel. Originally, Tarantino was to write one story, his friend Roger Avary was to write a second, and an unknown third director would write a third. The three would then each shoot their story and create an anthology film. This idea was quickly abandoned when a third voice never materialized and both Tarantino and Avary’s stories became longer than was intended. Tarantino described his intent with the film thusly: “the idea was basically to take the oldest chestnuts you’ve ever seen when it comes to crime stories—the oldest stories in the book.” What emerged from this exercise was Pulp Fiction, which would win Tarantino and Avary Oscars for Best Original Screenplay and would change movies for the foreseeable future.



Pulp Fiction is centered around three classic crime fiction stories: the idea of the heavy (John Travolta, who was nominated for Best Actor and had a major comeback due to the film) taking out the boss’ wife (Uma Thurman, who was nominated for Best Supporting Actrss), the idea of the boxer (Bruce Willis) paid to take the fall in a fight, and the idea of two hitmen (Travolta and Samuel L. Jackson, who as nominated for Best Supporting Actor) taking on a seemingly simple task. Tarantino cites Kiss Me Deadly, a short film called Curdled,Jean-Luc Godard's Bande a Parte (which was also the inspiration for the name of his production company, A Band Apart) and dozens of other films as inspiration. Yet Tarantino’s non-linear storytelling, predilection for letting these venerable tropes of crime fiction veer off the established rails, use of surf-rock and ‘70s tunes, and pop-culture savvy dialogue are the real legacies of Pulp Fiction, inspiring legions of imitators.



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eRVm_TAE24A



Following the widespread success and critical praise of Pulp Fiction, Tarantino wanted to adapt the work of another, both to alleviate the pressure of following up what some were calling a masterpiece, and to put his own touches on the work of another. He adapted Elmore Leonard’s Rum Punch, changing the race of the main character and creating a noir movie that also commented on the conventions of blaxploitation. The result, 1997’s Jackie Brown, follows the titular smuggler (Pam Grier) as she plans to play her gun-running boss Ordell (Samuel L. Jackson) against the ATF and agent Ray Nicolette (Michael Keaton) to talk away with $500,000 of smuggled money. With the help of an infatuated bail bondsman (Robert Forster) and working against some of Ordell’s heavies (including Robert De Niro), Jackie plays both sides against each other in an increasingly elaborate game of cat and mouse.



Inspired by Leonard’s novel, as well as many blaxploitation films, especially those actually starring Pam Grier (including Black Mama, White Mama, Coffy, and Foxy Brown) and even including an opening homage to The Graduate, Jackie Brown continues to be Tarantino’s least appreciated and referenced movie, which leaves the film criminally underrated. Smart, savvy, complex and flat-out fun, Jackie Brown is certainly Tarantino’s most straight forward film to date, yet it still retains his artful touches.



Tarantino has spent the last decade exploring the genres he most loves exceedingly closely, making films that can at times seem more like long-form homages than blazingly original works, yet he has never lost the ability to make his movies his own. Kill Bill, his fourth film (and his fifth, if you consider the cleaved movie two separate films) is at heart his most epic homage, a four hour love letter to the revenge drama that is heavily influenced by the traditions of Hong Kong martial arts films, Spaghetti Westerns, Japanese Chanbara films and exploitation movies. The movie follows the vengeful quest of The Bride (Uma Thurman) an assassin left for dead on her wedding day by her ex-lover Bill (David Carradine) and his cabal of assassins, who awakens from a coma four years later and sets out to take bloody vengeance on those who tried to kill her. The film(s) follow her gore-filled quest for revenge in a (who’s surprised) non-linear fashion as she tracks down and dispatches Vernita Green (Vivica A. Fox), O-Ren Ishii (Lucy Liu), Budd (Michael Madsen) and Elle Driver (Daryl Hannah) all on her path to finally coming face to face with the love of her life and the man who tried to murder her, the shockingly sympathetic and intuitive Bill.






Directly inspired by Lady Snowblood (which follows a woman murdering the gang that killed her family), the film also contains direct references to Samurai Reincarnation, Kage no Gundan, and Shogun Assassin, as well as more subtle homages to en grym film, Jackass: The Movie, Grease and dozens of others. At the core of the movie, though, is Tarantino’s deeply felt passion for the character, his pop-culture sensibility, his musical taste, and his nigh-magical way with words.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mo8ZM7PyRzU





Tarantino followed Kill Bill with his most direct homage yet: Grindhouse, a double feature anthology he co-directed with Robert Rodriguez as a mainstream re-creation of the run down nature of B-movies and the theaters that the two had frequented as kids. As such, both halves of the film (Rodriguez’ zombie movie Planet Terror and Tarantino’s vehicular slasher flick Death Proof) are shot on grainy film, contain missing reels, and are generally written and performed to evoke the poor production values of the exploitation movies of the ‘70s.



Tarantino’s half of the film, Death Proof, tells of a deranged stuntman (Kurt Russell) who stalks women and murders them by causing car crashes, which he is sure to survive because he has made his car “death proof.” Tarantino structured the movie on slasher films, but did not want to make a direct slasher film because of the rigid rules of the genre. So instead he used the basic plot points to create something different, a film about a misogynist that becomes a triumphant celebration of feminism by its closing shot.



Following Grindhouse, which was critically acclaimed but did poorly at the box office, Tarantino finally put into production the screenplay he had been working on for over a decade: Inglourious Basterds. A World War II epic more satisfyingly read as a Tarantino treatise on how he makes his films, the movie includes references to all of his previous works in addition to having as its thesis the idea that cinema can completely reform the world, changing history and our perceptions for at least the run-time of a great movie. Ostensibly following the titular band of Jewish soldiers turned ruthless Nazi hunters, lead by Lt. Aldo Raine (Brad Pitt) and including BJ Novak, Eli Roth, and Samm Levine, the film quickly becomes more of an espionage thriller than a war film as The Basterds, with the help of a British spy (Michael Fassbender) and a German double Agent (Diane Kruger) aim to use the premiere of a new German film as a chance to assassinate the German High Command, including Joseph Goebbels (Sylvester Groth) and Hitler himself (Martin Wuttke). As they prepare to execute their plan, a similar effort to destroy the attendees of the premiere is being plotted by an escaped Jew who owns the cinema under an assumed identity (Melanie Laurent) and her lover (Jacky Ido). However, each plan may be foiled by the brilliant, seductively evil Nazi “Jew Hunter” Hans Landa (Christoph Waltz, who won Best Supporting Actor for his seductively sinister, linguistically acrobatic performance) who seems constantly a few steps ahead of his adversaries.







Where each of Tarantino’s previous films heavily references cinematic history, Inglourious Basterds focuses more heavily on referencing the way that Tarantino himself makes movies. His tendency towards pop-culture references, ‘70’s music and non-linear storytelling are all given attention, and he directly references each of his own films within the movie. Perhaps most telling, then, is the film’s last line, when Aldo Raine looks right into the camera and says, “This just might be my masterpiece.”


Tarantino has built his career on his near encyclopedic knowledge of film history and his ability to rework and recycle the best of genre fare, yet his true success as a filmmaker comes from his ability to make what he “steals” his own. While Reservoir Dogs, Pulp Fiction, Jackie Brown, Kill Bill, Grindhouse, and Inglourious Basterds all owe huge debts to movies that came before, none of them are as excellent as they are because of the movies they reference. Each has a distinct sensibility, and a unique sense of humor that belongs to Tarantino alone. Like many people of the generation in which Tarantino came of age (and in subsequent generations, including my own), the world is best viewed through the lens of pop culture. Yet using the realm as a looking glass into the world at large need not distort one’s individual voice and perspective. Rather, in Tarantino’s case, it appears to have magnified that distinct authorial voice, and helped to cement him as one of the most influential and important filmmakers of our time.


Read more Whose Film Is It Anyway? here

Coming up on Who's Film Is It Anyway?:

3/13: Hal Ashby

3/27: Michael Bay

4/10:Aaron Sorkin

4/24: Christopher Nolan

Want to keep tabs on all of our updates? follow us on twitter @reviewtobenamed (follow us here).

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Feature: Jordan's Movie Quest: The Year 1941

Due to the intense amount of movie watching required to complete Whose Film Is It Anyway? on a biweekly basis, my movie quest has been slowed substantially in the past year (my look at 1940 was eight months ago, which is far too slow to be a realistic pace to keep). However, I have finally completed my look at 1941. After the stellar year that was 1940, it was inevitable there would be a downturn in cinematic quality. The Year 1941 was not nearly as solid as the one before it, but it did have some solid cinematic moments, including one widely considered the greatest film of all time. So here are my top ten movies of 1941, with a blurb on each.

10. Sergeant York-Sometimes a performance is better than the movie built around it, and that is certainly the case with Sergeant York. Played by Gary Cooper in an Academy Award winning turn, Alvin York is a ne’er-do-well who turns his life around after being struck by lightning and ends up becoming a hero in World War I. A celebration of patriotism and a testament to the ability of man to improve himself, Sergeant York is carried by the stellar performance of Gary Cooper, a legend for his easy portrayals of American masculinity.

9. Road to Zanzibar-Similar in construction and execution to its predecessor, Road to Singapore, yet improved by the increased chemistry between its stars, Road to Zanzibar follows con-artist Chuck Reardon (Bing Crosby) and his sidekick Hubert “Fearless” Frazier (Bob Hope) on a trek across Africa, fleeing from one failed scheme to the next in the company of fellow con artists Julia Quimby (Una Merkel) and Donna LaTour (series co-star Dorothy Lamour). Containing the winning mix of Crosby’s crooning and his quick banter and physical comedy with Hope, Road to Zanzibar’s success guaranteed the continuation of the “Road to…” series by becoming a well-deserved hit.

8. Sullivan’s Travels-A classic story of the disconnect of Hollywood and the power of laughter, the film follows comedy director John Sullivan (Joel McCrea) as he decides to make a drama about the problem of poverty, tentatively entitled O Brother Where Art Thou? (Coen fans will understand the significance of the title). When Sullivan realizes he knows nothing of poverty, he decides to hit the road as a tramp and experience the hard knock life. Accompanied by a failed actress (Veronica Lake) and tailed by a band of studio employees required to ensure his safety, Sullivan sets out to experience the real world first hand, and along the way discovers that comedy can make life livable for the truly downtrodden. Written and directed by the brilliant Preston Sturges, the film is a testament to the power of humor and of love, as hilarious as it is insightful, and a sheer joy to watch.

7. The Little Foxes-Regina Giddens (Bette Davis, in an Oscar nominated role) wants wealth and the freedom it brings, but is saddled in the early 20th century Southern culture that considers sons as the only legitimate heirs to a fortune. Because of this, her greedy brothers Benjamin (Charles Dingle) and Oscar (Carl Benton Reid) are wealthy and Regina is forced to rely on her sickly husband Horace (Herbert Marshall) for financial support. When her brothers plan to build a cotton mill, Regina will stop at nothing to ensure she benefits financially from the deal. A tour de force by Davis, The Little Foxes is a vicious, ruthless, and blackly insightful look into the nature of avarice and the consequences of ambition.

6. Suspicion-Johnnie Aysgarth (Cary Grant) charms Lina McLaidlaw (Joan Fontaine) into marrying him before she realizes he expects to live off of the generosity of her father (Sir Cedric Hardwicke). When a friend and investment partner of Johnnie’s winds up dead, Lina becomes convinced that her husband murdered him and is plotting to kill her for her life insurance. A taut thriller directed by undisputed master of the craft Alfred Hitchcock, Suspicion is a tense examination of the nature of paranoia and the dangers of slowly encroaching fear.

5. High Sierra-Roy “Mad Dog” Earle (Humphrey Bogart) is released from prison and wants to go straight, though he quickly learns he has been freed at the whim of crime lord Big Mac (Donald MacBride) to lead a gang in a heist at a California casino. On his cross country trip to the site of the heist in the Sierra mountains, Roy meets and falls for the disabled Velma (Joan Leslie), a kind hearted girl who Roy thinks might be his redemption. When she refuses his offer of marriage, Roy takes up with gangster’s moll Marie (Ida Lupino) and when the heist goes awry, the two go on the lam from the law. A surprisingly affecting story of a man who trying to make himself better and often failing, High Sierra is filled to the brim with noir dialogue, excellent performances, and earned emotions.

4. Penny Serenade-A frame tale centered on the reflections of Julie Adams (Irene Dunne) as she prepares to leave her husband Roger (Cary Grant, who was nominated for an Oscar for his performance), Penny Serenade follows through flashback the development and potential dissolution of the couple’s relationship. From a miscarriage in Japan to the struggle to adopt, and then keep, a baby, the film follows the couple’s struggle to build a life together and to keep that life from falling apart. Featuring excellent supporting performances by Edgar Buchanan and Beulah Bondi and solid direction by George Stevens, Penny Serenade is a prime example of an effective melodrama: moving but never maudlin, well acted, emotionally resonant and finally mournfully inspirational.

3. The Lady Eve-Written and Directed by screwball genius Preston Sturges, The Lady Eve follows Jean Harrington (Barbara Stanwyck in a hilarious and sexy performance), a gorgeous con artist who sets her sights on the rich but painfully shy snake expert Charles Pike (Henry Fonda) as they travel on a luxury cruise. She of course falls in love with him, but when her treachery is revealed, he leaves her and she, determined to re-enter his life, masquerades as Lady Eve Sidwich. Hysterical, complex, and perfectly executed, the film was nominated for an Academy Award for Best Writing, Original Story (the '40's version of Best Original Screenplay), and is a prime example of a comedy icon at the top of his game.

2. The Maltese Falcon-Sam Spade (Humphrey Bogart) finds himself embroiled in an increasingly complex web of double crosses and hidden agendas when his partner (Jerome Cowan) is killed while on a seemingly routine reconaissance. At the center of the mystery seems to be a theoretically priceless statue of a falcon and everyone from the woman who hired him (Mary Astor) to the mysterious Joel Cairo (Peter Lorre) and the sinister "Fat Man" Kasper Gutman (Sydney Greenstreet, who was nominated for Best Supporting Actor for his performance). Widely considered the first major film noir, The Maltese Falcon is full of the signature dialogue, characterizations, and mood that would come to represent the genre. Tense, frenetically paced, well acted and almost perfectly executed, The Maltese Falcon (which was also nominated for Best Picture and Best Adapted Screenplay) truly is "the stuff that dreams are made of."

1. Citizen Kane-So widely acclaimed that Roger Ebert once quipped, "So, its settled: Citizen Kane is the official greatest film of all time" its almost impossible to imagine the film living up to its hype. And while I can say its unlikely Citizen Kane will end up being my favorite movie of all time, it is an incredible cinematic achievement, representing a sea change in cinema that solidified the medium as an art form. When Charles Foster Kane (Orson Welles, who was nominated for Best Actor and Best Director, and won Best Writing) dies alone in his house, his last word, "Rosebud" sparks a search by Jerry Thompson (William Alland) into the past of the vastly wealthy media mogul to discover the meaning of his last words and to capture the measure of the man. Citizen Kane is a fascinating examination of a larger than life man with an even larger ego, and a look at what can be lost when one gains the world. Nominated for nine Academy Awards, including Best Picture (which it lost to the much less stellar How Green Was My Valley), Citizen Kane stands as one of the greatest films ever made, and perhaps the first movie to ever show the potential of the medium.

Sunday, February 13, 2011

Whose Film Is It Anyway?: George Lucas

By Jordan

Note: The purpose of Whose Film Is It Anyway? is to examine the validity of the auteur theory through the lens of individual film-makers, taking a look at their bodies of work and highlighting the technical elements, personal style, and thematic consistency of their films. Ultimately, the goal of this column will be to generate a discussion of the merits of auteur theory through examinations of directors widely considered auteurs, analyses of directors whose status as auteurs is more tenuous, and occasional looks at non-directors who may drive the quality and content of their films with more assuredness than the directors they work with.

“Do or do not. There is no try.”-Yoda (Frank Oz), The Empire Strikes Back

George Lucas changed the face of the film industry vastly, permanently, and entirely. But probably not in the way you think, and not always for the better. Over a career that has now spanned 40 years, he directed just six movies, and wrote only four by himself (though he had co-writers on three others, bringing his screenplay count up to seven). He has been vastly more productive as a producer and as a creative force than he ever will be as a writer or a director. And while it’s possible, and even easy to lob criticisms at him as a terrible writer and a director who peaked years before his most famous film, no one can claim that he isn’t a visionary as an idea man.

The way he reshaped the film industry has little to do with this though, at least on the surface. Saying that George Lucas invented the independent film scene as we now know it is slightly inaccurate (there were independent films before him that followed a model more similar to the way they are made today than what he pioneered), yet in the way that really matter, George Lucas invented the independent film scene. By the time of his second feature as a director, 1973’s American Graffiti (which we will talk about in a moment), he had already created Lucasfilm, the production company that would release one of the biggest films of all time on its own just four years later. George Lucas made Star Wars (or, as its now more popularly known, Star Wars: Episode IV: A New Hope), a big budget smash hit, completely outside of the studio system.

You know what else George Lucas did that completely and inexorably altered the movie-making landscape? He invented the now completely inseparable idea of merchandising for his movies. As he put it himself, “I figured if I got posters and T-shirts and things with the name of the movie on it, it would help promote the movie. The whole idea that licensing would be a revenue stream didn't occur to anybody.” Every time you slept in your Star Wars sheets as a kid (or, for some of you, as a slightly embarrassing adult), every time you laughed at Yogurt’s schtick in Spaceballs, and pretty much every poster that was probably hanging in your room as a kid, even the ones that on the surface had nothing to do with George Lucas, really only exist because of George Lucas. Add to that what THX has done to improve the sound in movie theaters, making itself an omnipresent force nationwide (though the current incarnation has nothing to do with Lucas, it was developed by Lucasfilm to ensure that the fidelity of the sound in Return of the Jedi would be of high quality across the country), and the groundbreaking work both on the Star Wars films and in general contributed to special effects by ILM (Industrial Light & Magic), and George Lucas becomes one of the most instrumental forces in our entire conception of modern cinema.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xvmZ9SPcTzU

But taking a step back, for a moment, to look at Lucas as a filmmaker, you’ll notice that his body of work is miniscule, and a full half of his movies as a writer and as a director are, too put it mildly, worse than two Holocausts. It wasn’t always that way, though. When THX 1138 was released in 1971, people pretty much just thought it was worse than a small Eastern European genocide. The film was produced by Lucas and Francis Ford Coppola based on a short film Lucas had made while in film school at USC. When the duo brought the finished film to Warner Bros, who had recently loaned Coppola $300,000 to open his own studio, American Zoetrope, Warner Bros. wanted their money back, and forced Lucas to cut down the film before its release. The debt that THX 1138 put American Zoetrope in forced Coppola to reluctantly take on another project to keep his studio afloat. And that unenthusiastic project would grow up to be The Godfather. For those of you keeping score at home, that means that in addition to being responsible for the flaming abortion that is the prequel trilogy, George Lucas also unwittingly brought us The Godfather. Sure, he re-edited his movies so Greedo shoots first and Jabba the Hutt has terrible musical taste, but his blunders also brought us Marlon Brando and Robert De Niro’s incendiary portrayals of Vito Corleone (I’m conjecturing here, that if Coppola hadn’t made The Godfather, he never would have made Part II, which I think a fair assumption). Where does that leave Lucas karmically? This is a question that will probably keep me up nights.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K6Z2ag8FMZw





THX 1138 was far from a commercial success (though it did recoup its budget), and was critically dismissed at the time (though it did receive fairly good reviews), which is kind of surprising considering its easily Lucas’ best directed film. It follows the titular THX (Robert Duvall) on his quest to escape the strictures of his totalitarian society where love is prohibited and free thinking greatly discouraged. In Lucas’ mind, it seems, the distant past was a time of enlightenment when good could triumph over evil (let’s not forget, fellow film geeks, that Star Wars is set “a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away…”), but the future is a dystopian nightmare where people can’t grow hair, fall in love, or pursue their dreams. This might shed more light on Lucas’ film career than it seems. In his early days, he made a very good sci-fi film that criticized consumerism and mirrored his own personal struggle for artistic freedom in a studio system that wouldn’t allow him to shine. Yet within a decade after the release of THX 1138 he had fallen down the rabbit hole, changing his mind about the original intended death of Han Solo because he worried it might hurt action figure sales. Oh, how the mighty had fallen (by becoming insanely more rich and successful than I can even conceive of, both because he had a lot of money and because counting has never been my greatest strength).



If Star Wars can be viewed as the beginning of Lucas’ artistic death, as the point right before his creative integrity was devoured by his own marketing ingenuity like an Ouroboros of getting rich off of action figures instead of great movies, then American Graffiti can be seen in a whole new light. It exists as Lucas’ second feature, and his last movie within the studio system (it was co-produced by Universal Pictures, in addition to The Coppola Company and the new Lucasfilm), as another example of an assured director gaining confidence along with his experience, and as the point at which cineastes had to stand up and recognize Lucas as a potential filmic force to be reckoned with. It became a sleeper hit commercially and garnered high critical praise, basically cementing Lucas’ place alongside Coppola, Speilberg, and Scorsese as a member of the “film school brats” of the early 1970’s. The film follows one wild night in the small town America of the early 1960’s, as two recent high school graduates (Richard Dreyfuss and Ron Howard) prepare to leave the town behind to go off to college. A series of thinly tied together vignettes that examine nostalgia, hope, fear of the unknown, love, lust, friendship, milkshakes, sock hops, and fast cars, American Graffiti is a film that encapsulates an idea, and an era so well that it guaranteed Lucas would be taken seriously and solidified him as a director of great promise.



I did suggest nary a paragraph ago that Star Wars might be viewed as the beginning of Lucas’ artistic death, and I want to clarify that I in no way mean that as a criticism of the film, which can only be described as awesome times infinity. Like pretty much everyone born between, say, 1970 and 1992 (I’m approximating here the year in which someone might have been old enough to have seen and fully absorbed the Original Trilogy before the release of the New Trilogy could have tainted their associations with Star Wars), the film is completely engrained into the way I view the world, and I’m not even sure that qualifies as comic hyperbole. I was raised on Star Wars, grew up on Star Wars, and still watch it at least once a year. Star Wars is very likely one of the reasons I approach the world with the pop culture obsessiveness that I do. So when I say that it may have precipitated Lucas’ creative death, I do not mean that Star Wars wasn’t a great movie; on the contrary, I think it may have been too good.



Think about it this way: when In the Aeroplane Over the Sea was released, Jeff Mangum effectively retired from making new music (at least so far, anyway, and a guy can dream, right?). I have always viewed this retirement as a sort of admission that the art, and the pressure that comes from creating great art, beat him. What I mean is that In the Aeroplane Over the Sea is pretty much the perfect album. Knowing he had made a masterpiece, I can imagine it would be difficult, if not impossible, to imagine returning to the studio to make more music. Whatever you did, it would inevitably be compared to your previous work, and it would probably pale by comparison. This is a theory I also ascribe to Harper Lee, who wrote To Kill a Mockingbird and then never put pen to paper again. Once you’ve made your masterpiece, it may be very difficult to try again. To a certain extent, what's the point?

In the same way, I wonder if Star Wars didn’t beat Lucas. He was just blossoming as a director when it was released, and it was the first script he had written by himself. Where THX 1138 had been a commercial failure and American Graffiti a sleeper success, Star Wars was made for a budget of $11 million and grossed $307,263,857 in its initial theatrical release (and in total to date has, by itself grossed over $775 million). And while both of his previous movies had received decent reviews, the praise for Star Wars was nearly unanimous (Though a few critics, including Pauline Kael, Peter Keough, and Stanley Kauffman panned the movie). Virtually from the moment of the film’s release, the world clamored for a sequel.



And at that point, Lucas just stopped. He wrote the story for The Empire Strikes Back, but the screenplay was written by Leigh Brackett and Lawrence Kasdan, and the film was directed by Irvin Kershner. He co-wrote Return of the Jedi with Kasdan, but that was directed by Richard Marquand (after tragically being turned down by David Lynch, who knew he wouldn’t get the freedom he required working with Lucas) and had begun production based on Lucas’ story long before the screenplay was ever written. While Lucas was instrumental to the creation of another of film’s most successful franchises, Indiana Jones, he served as a producer and story consultant on all of those films, never writing or directing any of them. He produced numerous films in the decades following the release of Star Wars, and even contributed ideas to some (though his creative ideas seem to experience diminishing marginal returns, as by 1988 when he produced The Land Before Time, he is credited only with coming up with the fairly obvious idea that the female triceratops should be named Cera), but for a long time it seemed like his desire to write and direct were completely gone.

Until, 22 years after his last directorial effort, Lucas stepped behind the camera again for The Phantom Menace, only his second film as a solo writer-director. Steve Wilson of Salon.com may have framed the problem with the film best when he said, “Perhaps the absolute creative freedom that director George Lucas enjoyed […] with no studio execs and not many an independently minded actor involved—is a path to the dark side.” After a two decade long hiatus from writing and directing, Lucas decided to take on a task that is Sisyphusean at best and to do so with no outside input. There was probably no way that Lucas could have made a film that surpassed the original trilogy; maybe even trying was a fool’s errand. Yet I’m not sure Lucas made the film as a true artistic endeavor.



There’s a distinct possibility that after being consumed by his marketing acumen decades earlier, his artistic impulses were too dormant to be awakened. But after going through a messy and costly divorce in 1987, and seeing the enduring popularity of his universe, Lucas began to develop the prequel trilogy in the early 1990s. That the new trilogy was a mercenary marketing decision intended to make Lucas millions upon millions of dollars regardless of their obvious lack of quality is a tragedy if it’s true, but at the same time it might soften the blow of their awfulness just a little. If George Lucas wasn’t trying and was just in it for the money, that makes him kind of a reprehensibly human being, but isn’t it slightly better than the idea that the man who created Star Wars and Indiana Jones became not just creatively barren but actively bad at coming up with and executing his ideas? I would rather live in a world where the new trilogy and Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull were just moneymaking schemes inflicted on the general public because Lucas knows we’re all saps and wants to line his gold pockets with a few pieces of silver than exist in a world where Lucas died creatively around 1984 and ambled around Skywalker Ranch as an artistic zombie for the rest of his life turning out schlock and thinking it gold. Call it the optimist in me.





George Lucas has a much smaller body of work than many of the directors I have covered in this column previously, yet the work he did do has been vastly influential. Lucas altered the way movies are made and the way they are watched in a way that is so complete it’s almost impossible to describe his influence. And yes, at the end of the day a full half of his directorial efforts are terrible, terrible movies, but they’re also his catastrophes. No one else in the world could fail that spectacularly and just keep trudging on. The critical drubbing that ensued after The Phantom Menace might have deterred someone with less will or more respect for his fan base, but Lucas pushed on, turning out Attack of the Clones and Revenge of the Sith, and reviving the Indiana Jones franchise with an idea so awful only he could have pushed it into theaters. When David Lynch turned down the opportunity to direct Return of the Jedi, it was because he knew the movie would be Lucas’ no matter who directed it. A vision as strong as his cannot be subsumed, no matter the cost to his reputation or to his soul. It’s kind of poetic, really, that Lucas in a way followed the advice of one of his most famous characters (in a line he almost certainly didn’t write). He did. Then he did not. But if one thing can be said of the modern Lucas, it’s that with him, there is no try.


Read more Whose Film Is It Anyway? here

Coming up on Who's Film Is It Anyway?:

2/27: Quentin Tarantino

3/13: Hal Ashby

3/27: Michael Bay

4/10:Aaron Sorkin